One question, how are these fish people efficiently swimming? From what I can tell, aside from plastic gills, they do not have any huge physical alterations. Being a former competitive swimmer myself, I can tell you that while human beings can find ways to move fairly quickly through the water, without a different body structure and fins, they just don’t seem very efficient as a food gathering device.
Tony just showed me what these fish people look like. Terrifying if you ask me.
Near the end of the adventure, after they all make it back to the TARDIS, Jamie admits that he feels safe in the TARDIS. Oh, to be somewhere safe, where no menace can touch you. Hopefully we all know what a comforting feeling that is.
- Story Grade: B
Eight months after viewing and I can honestly say that I did NOT
forget a thing remember a thing.
*checks wikipedia for notes, reads Jael’s commentary, digs for own notes, eliminates distractions by stopping Coupling from playing in the background*
Alright, I’m back.
Right, The Underwater Menace. Jamie’s first time traveling with the Doctor… and the story is 50% missing. The good news is that the missing episodes will be animated, but the bad news is that they were not animated in time for this blog – don;t be surprised to see revisions/double reviews in the future, as more stories are found, animated, or released.
In this story the old tale of Atlantis is played with for the first of three times in the history of the ever-expanding Doctor Who. The most frightening thing is the idea of converting people into “fish-people”. There is something much more scary about this compared to the idea of being converted into a cyberman. At least with a cyberman you are essentially dead and completely different; when converted to a fish-person you are still rather human, but now have to deal with the still very real issues of living in the sea. Giving up everything you once new on the surface and being thrown into a crazy water-world seems terrifying.
Polly still seems rather useless, but what can you expect in a story where she is not the only companion AND a female character written in the 60s. Stick ing with the companions, I hope you like Jamie, because he’ll be sticking around for quite some time.
- Story Grade: C
- Not exactly a historical, not exactly pure fiction, this is a Who-take on an old tale – Atlantis. Please, do not let science create fish people!
Thank you to the costume designer who created the fish person costume. Though this is not a story on DVD yet, the still photos and partial clips make this ballet outfit look flat-out ridiculously terrifying.
See what I mean?