Right away this reminds me of The Prisoner. Does that make me über-nerdy? I guess the difference is that I stuck with the Doctor through this entire adventure to eventually find out why this colony is odd and slightly disturbing at first glance. I do not think I have gotten through a season of The Prisoner. Isn’t it funny how in both cases extreme pleasantness and “happiness” is stressed, even though the population is basically a captive slave force.
Jamie knows there is trouble. He tells Polly to keep her eyes peeled and distrusts the voice that speaks while they sleep. But the real mystery to me is, what does Jamie look like when in the words of Polly he looked so “smashing”? Did they do something different with his hair?? Regardless I am liking him as a companion. Very reliable and loyal with a bit of a rebellious side.
Ben on the other hand, I am not a fan of Ben’s.
The messages in this story were not very subtle. Make up your own mind and do not be unquestioningly obedient. At least they are not bad messages. Oh, another subtle message, “violence will get you nowhere.”
The whole story I was wondering where they have these stupid recordings singing instructions and “inspiration” to the workers. Turns out the colony has its own version of a Glee Club. Oh joy. And similar to current day glee clubs, it is overbearing and extremely annoying. Yay.
- Story Grade: B-
I find reading my lovely wife’s reviews to be hilarious and confusing. I shouldn’t be so confused, after all, she has told me that she does NOT want to grade the stories, but I cannot help it. Maybe it’s the guy part of me, or maybe we are just that different, but I cannot understand how she “rates” these serials/stories. Reading her review above, I would have expected a C-level grade at the very best, but somehow she is in the B-range. “B-range” to me is significantly above average as a story, though not quite to the classic level which an “A” would garner.
Rebuttals to Jael’s Review:
- The Prisoner?! Nice reference, but we’ve only watched about 5-6 episodes of the series. I’d say it would have almost been a badge of nerdery, but wait until completion to display that honor. Now if you just meant The Simpson’s form of The Prisoner, I’ll let you display that proudly, though I have more pride in the fact that I converted you into a Simpsons fan.
- Do you also see this as an early version of The Happiness Patrol? I know that mentioning a 7th Doctor story would be incredibly out of order, but we’ve both seen it.
- Your approval of Jamie is nothing more than a love of the Scottish accent and similar heritage of your ancestors in their Irish homeland (heck, they probably are intertwined, as I am sure they liked to mingle with one another). As for smashing Jamie? We’ll never know, since all 4 stories are lost to time.
- You don’t like Ben?! Shocking. Maybe you just like Jamie too much. 😉
- I do agree with your assessment of the subtlety in this story. Being mindless slaves in order to be happy does not actually produce happy people, but just numb and distant shells of humans.
- Your hate towards the Glee club makes me happy. I am so thrilled that I am with someone who does not want to watch Glee. Thank you.
As for my two cents? This story has crabs. Giant crabs. I find it a bit hilarious and even ambitious that Doctor Who even tried to show these characters on screen. Today we have special effects, incredible design/costume teams, and we still do not show everything on screen. While nothing about the 1960s-era Who is completely believable (heck, most of Classic Who is under-budget, but that’s part of the charm), at least they pushed the envelop. Much like the guys from Radio Free Skaro, I, too, would absolutely LOVE it if they produced a new-Who with a cheap budget and nearly 100% set/costume design, instead of graphics and tech wizardry.
It’s unfortunate for Ben and Polly’s characters that The Doctor and Jamie work so well together. This is probably the reason why Jamie stays and the other two go in the not so distant future (OK, maybe the next story. *SPOILERS!*).
While a bit silly, I will not let the fact that this story is 100% audio bring down my grade…
- Story Grade: B-
- A bit of fun and your typical feel-good happy ending. While not 100% the same, the giant bugs and Macra make it feel like Planet of Giants, which was quite enjoyable.
Thanks again to Patrick Troughton for the breath of fresh air. It’s easy to see why Doctor Who kept building into the show that is so loved now with Patrick as the lead. His appeal to children is obvious, and I wouldn’t mind being old if I aged like his character.
PS: Look out for the Macra in the new series episode “Gridlock.”